Desperate to advance his cause, Marcus roused the leader of the group, Khan Noonien Singh, and held the rest of Khan's people hostage while Khan himself was forced to develop advanced weapons for the Federation under the secretive Section 31. For now, the three films released in the early 21st century are as Star Trek as it gets while remaining a little pocket universe for folks to enjoy on its own merits. In fact, even though Star Trek: The Animated Series isn't itself canon, many concepts introduced in the show became essential parts. All Discovery is doing is actually showing that sort of thing. Well, the answer was the introduction of an alternate reality that would link the new Star Trek film series to past canon, while also allowing filmmakers to go their own way. Warning: SPOILERS for Star Trek: Discovery season 3, episode 9, "Terra Firma, Part 1". All that talk of respect and consistency still leaves room for surprises. There are many notable differences: Kirks father died on the Kelvin, and he joined Starfleet three years later than in the Prime timeline. The prime timeline is licensed to CBS Studios, and they cannot use material from Paramount's Kelvin timeline, and vice versa. New One Piece trailer introduces us to an oceans worth of rivals, threats, and pirates, The Walking Dead: first trailer and new title for Rick & Michonne series, 16 years later, baby Bonsly is finally getting a new Pokmon card. The Franklins captain, Balthazar Edison, now known as Krall, rejects Starfleet ideals of peace. The resulting confrontation led to Kelvin timeline Spock seeking the advice of Spock Prime, who recalled the deadly consequences of battling Khan. A few comments I read before Star Trek: Discovery premiered indicated it was part of the original timeline, but after seeing the show I'm not 100% sure: many of the consoles we see here are similar to those in the current films. Well we saw that happen during Kirk's era. First of all, I don't really give two craps what any of the writers or producers are saying about. Could ChatGPT etcetera undermine community by making statements less significant for us? That's the Klingons. Certain that the admiral had already killed his people, Khan set out to become a one-man vengeance machine and destroy the Federation from the inside. Ambassador Spock attempted to use "red matter", a substance so powerful that a single drop can destroy a planet, to save Romulus by destroying the supernova. With Spock Prime's help including the introduction of transwarp beaming to the Kelvin timeline Kirk and Spock were able to make amends and defeat Nero before he could destroy Earth, cementing the dynamic of the Enterprise crew. While Nero arrived in the Kelvin timeline in 2233, Spock didn't actually emerge from the black hole until 25 years later, and he found the vengeful Romulan waiting for him. I did see a Klingon named Kol who is from a house called Kor, so, maybe Kor is leading Kol in an admiral type roll due to differences caused by the Kelvin event. If Discovery does take place in the original timeline, then Lorca's schematic may be an unused early model or conceptual refit sketch. Kelvin, killing. The movies of Star Trek's Kelvin Timeline exist in an entirely separate continuity to the franchise's Prime Universe, and though this development was entirely necessary to ensure the movies had a chance at success, the popularity of the Kelvin Timeline is utterly unique. The Kelvin was destroyed, and Nero's reign of terror continued in what was now an alternate reality. Order of events between Prime and Kelvin timelines. This version of James T. Kirk was a rebellious young man, joyriding in stolen cars as a teenager and getting into bar fights in his 20s. On the surface, the appearance and some of the more advanced tech matches the Kelvin timeline, with its more contemporary uniforms and more advanced ship. Classic Star Trek Continuity Kelvin Timeline Discovery Continuity Continuity Workaround at EAS The live-action TV series and movies produced by Star Trek's copyright owners are canon by definition. It would naturally revert in about a hundred years. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. The uniform suggested they were from the mid-24th century, around the time of The Next Generation series. Picard takes place long after the titular character has quit Starfleet, and early on we discover the destruction of Romulus was why. They had tried to produce Kilngon Augments. I understand Kirk didnt join Starfleet early because his father is dead. This contradicts previous canon that Replicators were a Next Generation era technology - Captain Janeway, in an episode of Voyager, states that in Captain Kirks time there were no replicators. Throughout Trek, stardates were used to keep time when ships were traveling faster than light. Star Trek first graced the small screen way back in the late 1960s, and since then it has been a staple in the science fiction adventure genre. In Into Darkness (2013), Alexander Marcus, leader of the secretive Section 31, finds the SS Botany Bay, stuffed to the rafters full of augmented humans in cryostasis. What's the DC of a Devourer's "trap essence" attack? Its now 2258 and Ambassador Spock emerges from the black hole just in time to be scooped up by Nero, who keeps the Jellyfish and its cache of red matter for himself while abandoning Spock on the frozen planet of Delta Vega. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. I'm not very good about the Star Trek lore can someone explain what the Kelvin and Prime timelines are and why they should (or shouldn't) be merged? This is one of the main story elements of the 2009 film Star Trek, which starts in the year 2380 in, interestingly, the prime timeline. DSC is dealing with the unification of the Empire. In the ptime timeline, this would not have occurred until TNG era and then only on a holodeck. Simply saying it doesn't make it so. If you want to rewatch the new Star Trek movies, our Star Trek streaming guide will show you where to watch them all online. Anyone who did know about it would just assume it had passed by now. Plus, in recent years, the inciting incident for this reality has become a jumping-off point for more stories in the Prime Star Trek reality, making it a major influence in two different universes. but also influenced modern day technology, Star Trek: The Klingon Language, Explained, and use time travel to create a whole new timeline, How Star Trek: The Next Generation Explored Blindness & Accessibility With Geordi LaForge, LOTR: The Battle Of Helms Deep, Explained, The Harry Potter Reboot Won't Have The Cameo Fans Really Want. Star Trek: How Picard Connects to Both the Prime and Kelvin Timelines - CBR If that were true, it makes everything we know about Voyager's doctor and the issuea he had with mobility really weird. Over 100 space rocks collected by meteorite hunter Geoffrey Notkin are up for action today, How California museum is protecting space shuttle Endeavour against earthquakes, Gorgeous photos show SpaceX's next Starship Super Heavy booster on the launch pad. What Star Trek movie/show are these images of a girl missing her school shuttle taken from? This is something more or less signposted in an early draft of the first Abrams movie, which includes dialogue where a young Spock is asked what the main assumption of quantum cosmology is and he answers, "everything that can happen does happen in equal and parallel universes. Star Trek's Kelvin Timeline Was Inevitable (But Its Success Is Unique) For example, Beverly Crusher once spent an episode . Speaking with Sci Fi Wire in 2009, Kurtzman explained, "Yeah, the biggest thing I think we all hiccuped on, just conceptually, when Trek was presented to us was, 'Well, we know how they all died. Remember, Enterprise had a Temporal Cold War with history changes and a huge Xindi war that never happened in the TOS/TNG/DS9/VOY universe. A malfunction there would certainly fit in with the priority one distress call the season ends on. So, following logically, this is still Prime Universe. This is clearly a reference to Nero, the Romulan villain of the 2009 movie, who instigated the alternate timeline when he traveled back a hundred years and destroyed the U.S.S. New games for 2023 and beyond to add to your wishlist, Your grandma was the biggest challenge for Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves, Gamescom 2023 schedule: Everything you need to know, Aidan Turner and the cast of Fifteen-Love on challenging your perception of MeToo dramas, Cillian Murphy talks Oppenheimer: Nolan is incomparable a totally unique filmmaker, Blimey, Sea of Thieves' Monkey Island expansion is off to a staggeringly boring start, Avengers, X-Men, Spider-Man and all of Marvel's October 2023 comics revealed, Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom's building is a game-changer, but Nintendo might have set its bar too high, The One Ring and Lord of the Rings Roleplaying are the RPGs Tolkien fans have always wanted, Accidentally finding Tears of the Kingdom's best ending after beating it was the coolest gaming experience I've had in years, All of The Conjuring Universe movies, ranked, Matt Damon talks his "fascinating" Oppenheimer general: "He didn't reflect on it at all", Cherry MX-LP 2.1 review: "endlessly portable", Playseat Trophy Logitech G Edition review: "Cleverly designed, well built, and mighty comfortable", Pikmin 4 review: "The most approachable Pikmin entry ever", Logitech G Pro X 2 review: "a worthy successor", Exoprimal review: "A messy blur of missiles and gnashing teeth", The Beanie Bubble review: "Zach Galifianakis transfixes in a playful tale that spills the beans", Oppenheimer review: "Christopher Nolan firing on all cylinders", Barbie review: to use Ken's words, "sublime", They Cloned Tyrone review: "A drawn-out but slyly funny conspiracy caper", Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One review: "When it delivers, it delivers big time", Secret Invasion episode 5 review: "Lurches from uninspired scene to uninspired scene", The Bear season 2 review: "A very different beast", Secret Invasion episode 4 review: "Has finally found its footing", Secret Invasion episode 3 review: "Another twist shakes up the formula", The Witcher season 3, volume 1 review: "Henry Cavills long goodbye carries plenty of promise", Takes you closer to the games, movies and TV you love, Try a single issue or save on a subscription, Issues delivered straight to your door or device. Still, by the time Picard debuted, the Kelvin Timeline and Prime Universe were loosely connected. You have to respect canon, stated Kurtzman in this interview. You know the one. Why is there no 'pas' after the 'ne' in this negative sentence? There are some things we do know though. Enraged, a Romulan mining ship captain named Nero sought vengeance, and he attacked Spock's one-man vessel with his own ship, the Narada. Released: July 6, 2016 Rewards Experience Points: 9159 Expertise: 9550 Dilithium Ore: 480 You will receive the following reward: [Kelvin Timeline Bat'leth Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Directed Energy Distribution Manifold Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Prefire Chamber Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Warhead Yield Chamber Mk XI] This included the development of the Vengeance, a powerful new Federation warship, and a new advanced torpedo design that Marcus hoped to use against the Klingons. Interestingly, when interviewed about season 2, co-creator Alex Kurtzman addressed the idea of who might be on the Enterprise, stating I think there will be some surprises there. And if you're curious to see how the new movies stack up against the classics, check out our Star Trek movies, ranked worst to best article. Kirk and the ships he encountered did not use them. To make matters worse, both his ship, the experimental Jellyfish, and the Romulan mining ship Narada were pulled into the black holes wake and sent hurtling backwards in time. Be prepared to see too many pictures of her dogs. trekmovie.com Leonard Nimoy appeared as an older Spock in the film, despite Zachary Quinto playing a younger version of that character. but only in minutiae of the Grand Scheme - Xindi war was to prevent forming the Federation, as this was the way to win the Temporal war. The starships look similar, for example, but the designs are altered in many ways, and the same is true of things like phasers, communicators, and Starfleet uniforms. @Thomas - I'm guessing the Terran Empire would have re-branded Defiant from USS to ISS, especially if they had upgraded it. 1 It's unclear if the schematic is from the rebel database or from Discovery's own records. Spock emerged in 2258 while the Romulans landed in 2233. Discovery Officially Makes JJ Abrams' Star Trek Movies Canon - Screen Rant Since we are doing this series in 2016, and all of the other series have been produced [at a time that] isnt as sophisticated as we are now with what we can do production-wise, were going to be reestablishing an entire look for the series not only for the series, but for what we wanted to accomplish with Star Trek beyond this series. Serious, in-depth discussion about *Star Trek.*. But if were going to get any answers its going to happen in season 2. He was able to save his father but not his human mother, who fell just as they were preparing to beam back up to the Enterprise. Yes I say that because of visuals. That looks more like TOS dating (which was of course all over the place and not consistent), where the first one given in "Where No Man Has Gone Before" was 1312.4 (2265). DSC uses extensive holography aboard Federation starships. By the end of that season, an operative from the shady intelligence agency Section 31, played by David Cronenberg of all people, revealed that an alien Starfleet officer from the Kelvin Timeline crossed into their timeframe. Until 2009, all canon Star Trek was set in the same timeline (although owing to time travel it was frequently subject to subtle changes). Eventually he finds himself fighting alongside Starfleet (after a bit of fibbing) aboard the iconic USS Enterprise. Creating the Kelvin timeline was a stroke of genius in a way, and while not being directly linked to the prime timeline, the films have still influenced proceeding additions to the franchise. As you've probably guessed, the Kelvin Ttmeline is so named because the destruction of the Kelvin is the event triggering the alternate reality. Sure we still have to explain the uniforms. Stuff should still happen way closer to their original time placements.. That means we have an inciting incident for the Kelvin timeline that also exists as a major, galaxy-altering event in the Prime timeline, and that means there are consequences for both realities. J.J. Abrams Star Trek movies take place in an alternate reality known as the Kelvin timeline and the events of the films happen within the timeframe of Discovery seasons 1 and 2 and Strange New Worlds in the Prime timeline. Let me first challenge by saying that if we favor a prime placement, we still need to resolve some problems. Kelvin vs Prime? : r/StarTrekDiscovery - Reddit There are other instances of course, where the original timeline is destroyed [EX:"Year of Hell" (VOY)], but the timeline in which Star Trek (2009) occurs does NOT destroy the original timeline. Star Trek: The Kelvin Timeline, Explained - Game Rant Simply saying it doesn't make it so. Although if youre a writer on a show, writing it down in a script. The Enterprise tries to stop him and fails, though they do manage to rescue Spocks father, Sarek. Plus, there are some huge inconsistencies with either timeline beyond the basics of Burnham being Spock's previously unmentioned half-sister, the fundamentally different looking Klingons (especially as this is the peak time for the more ordinary looking Klingons of the TOS, explained by a virus created from augmented human DNA), or the apparent near destruction of the Federation. Such huge discrepancies have been waved away by fans saying the Discoverys status as a military vessel gave it access to technology other ships of the time didnt have. The Klingons revised look should have been a revision of TOS era Klingons not modern Klingons. That it was shared in exchange for Klingon designs and hulls (as mentioned in TOS). He dispatched Kirk and the Enterprise to capture "Harrison" on the Klingon world Kronos, believing Kirk would simply kill the terrorist as an act of revenge. There, Data again talks about how all possibilities that can or could happen, do happen in alternate quantum realities. That episode sees numerous, slightly different versions of the Prime reality, separated by imperceptible differences (the colour of a cake, for example). That was before the Kelvin was destroyed. Desperate to save their people, the Romulans asked the United Federation of Planets for help. How to watch Star Trek in order | TechRadar In the Prime timeline, it was Spock who paid with his life before being revived. The practical upshot of all this is that, yes, all the talk seems to say that Discovery is in the Prime timeline. The writers of 2009's Trek film could have simply said, "We're starting over, but the other films and shows are all still there for you to watch." Paramount wanted a prequel film, showing what led Captain James T. Kirk and the much loved, much memed, Spock to where audiences see them in The Original Series. Farragut. However, there has been a little bit of crossover between the two. In fact at least one major one. Piece of evidence 3: the uniforms. The premise was that the Romulan Sun destabilized, and before Spock could save his alien cousins, the planet was destroyed. After learning that Spock Prime has died, though, he chooses to honor his alternate self's memory by remaining in Starfleet, as it's what Spock Prime was doing at the same age. After this attack, Marcus saw a path to killing his former hostage and covering up his military conspiracy at the same time. Bare with me. (I barely even want to mention the Spore Drive, as it's so canonically inconsistent.). When Kurtzman was eventually tapped to kick off the third wave of the Star Trek series, he stuck to what's known as the "Prime Universe" partly because of rights issues. Kirk et al save the day, of course. 7v7: Prime Timeline Starfleet vs Kelvin Timeline Starfleet - Reddit When Columbia was commissioned and launched, it had no holographic tech. Abrams' Movies Were Made With No Star Trek TV Shows But Things Have Changed Did Kirk's captaincy of the Enterprise have a canon starting date in TOS? Star Trek: How Picard Ties In With Kelvin Timeline - Screen Rant The Kelvin timeline or alternate reality was a parallel universe created in the year 2233 with the temporal incursion of the Narada, a Romulan civilian mining vessel under the command of Nero, from the year 2387. Lorca shows this schematic1: Although the schematic lists the ship as the USS (not ISS) Defiant, some features don't match the original, seen here (lower right) in "In a Mirror, Darkly, Part II"2 before the Empire had opportunity to modify it: For example, the wireframe has notches on the rim of the saucer, and a cylinder (parallel to the nacelle) at a bend in the nacelle pylon. So I will call it "Discovery Universe", as it is a bubble of completely different latex Canon tells us Klingons acquired cloaking tech from Romulans. The destruction of Romulan, an event that the 2009 Star Trek states takes place ion the prime timeline, plays as major context to the events of 2020s Picard. We are dealing with a visual medium here. Father, veteran, and storyteller. This means the Kelvin Timeline is as much a part of the canon as the Mirror Universe. Breaking space news, the latest updates on rocket launches, skywatching events and more! To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Also: i didn't see the Kor in this show.You know: the Dahar master, an important and honored general in the Federation war, THIS war.. Why did Khan come out of stasis so early and why did Kirk's five-year mission start in 2260 instead of 2265? They had to significantly alter the uniforms for the Kelvin timeline to be able to use them. Here's what that means within the franchise. And they are able to sit on chairs. See the HEART of @startrekcbs: it's real STAR TREK to its core.September 15, 2017, Theres no arguing that Discovery is Star Trek to its core but theres still so much that doesnt add up. And I mean it in the strategic sense, as they knew Kelvin was attacked by unknown species with a ship of unknown capabilities. There's a Prime timeline, a Kelvin one, the Mirror Dimension and more time travelling and universe hopping than several other shows combined. Early Tweets from Anthony Rapp, who plays astromycologist Lieutenant Paul Stamets in the show, seemed to clearly state Discovery is Prime timeline, Yes it is in the Prime timeline. As for the Kelvin timeline, it seems that there is now a created alternate timeline, where Spock didn't run off to the Guardian of Forever to prevent the contamination and save Romulus and Vulcan, which is where I hoped the story was going. It's even shown that Kelvin Timeline vessels can take more damage than Prime Timeline ships (most notably referenced by the Vengeance remaining structurally intact after that internal explosion of torpedoes). But holography was known much earlier. Directed by J.J. Abrams and starring Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto, and Zoe Saldana, Star Trek introduced the world to new versions of classic characters like Kirk, Spock, and Uhura, and it took us. as for the modifications couldn't they have been made by the empire after the acquisition? Everything we know about Zack Snyder's new Netflix space opera, Everything we know about Blue Beetle: Release date, plot, cast & more, Stonehenge's summer solstice orientation is seen in monuments all over the UK in amazing photos, Star Wars: Visions season 2 episodes, ranked, Out of this world accommodation: What sci-fi gets right (and wrong) about life beyond Earth, Watch SpaceX launch 22 Starlink satellites to orbit tonight, 2 Women's World Cup stadiums spied from space (satellite photos), NASA searches for climate solutions as global temperatures reach record highs, SpaceX rolls Starship Super Heavy booster back to the pad ahead of next launch (photos), Jam packed issues filled with the latest cutting-edge research, technology and theories delivered in an entertaining and visually stunning way, aiming to educate and inspire readers of all ages, Engaging articles, breathtaking images and expert knowledge. My question is, why does everything not add up correctly? During the chase, the two get caught in the gravitation pull of a black hole, which flings them back in time to the year 2233, over 150 years in the past. They still want to "seek out new life forms," but only to find out how dangerous they are. Visit our corporate site. Are you suggesting that the displays of TNG DS9 and VOY were all holographic as well? ST:D is - as is mentioned multiple times - is set about 10 years before Kirk's first mission, yet after Kelvin fork. Reddit, Inc. 2023. As the Kelvin is destroyed, it sets about the start of the new timeline, named in honor of the ships' sacrifice. The Naradas captain, Nero decides to use this opportunity to take out his grief on the organization he holds responsible for the ruin of Romulus and, by extension, the death of his family: the Federation. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Yes. They look nothing like the uniforms seen the show, either in "the present" (2256) or in the flashback set in 2249 when Burnham met Georgiou. We can redefine the visual style, he said. I also write reviews, previews and features, largely about horror, action adventure, FPS and open world games. Does the US have a duty to negotiate the release of detained US citizens in the DPRK? Scan this QR code to download the app now. Hes a soldier and he believes that he should be allowed to do what he does best. And when you know that, it's very difficult to put them in jeopardy in a way that feels fresh or original. TOS did have Rec Rooms that were capable of holographic projections but these were more movie-like projections that simulations. In the Prime Timeline, the Franklin is still stuck on Altamid, the Kelvin wasn't attacked and went on with its life, and in the Kelvin Timeline, the NX-01 is presumably at the Fleet Museum. A cunning warrior, the best star-pilot in the galaxy, and a good friend. Ok. I'm confused as hell after I saw the episode chronology recently posted on r/startrek. But the best stories are going to explain it not write it off. 3 This image is from the remastered version of the episode. Audiences are treaded to the same characters and baseline story, but from the perspective of an all new timeline. Published Dec 10, 2020 The 32nd century Federation in the Prime Universe knows JJ Abrams' Kelvin timeline exists, meaning Star Trek: Discovery united the entire franchise. What is the smallest audience for a communication that has been deemed capable of defamation? How do you ever have real stakes to your characters?" Star Trek: Major details revealed about new TV show, https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Harcourt_Fenton_Mudd?file=Harry_Mudd_police_record.jpg, Stack Overflow at WeAreDevelopers World Congress in Berlin, Favorite Question and Answers from Second Quarter 2023.
Depaul Hospital Visiting Hours, Morrison Ranch, Gilbert, Kecoughtan Soccer Schedule, Articles K